Our Beacon Forum

Sayings of Prophet Muhammad[AS]: Hadith or Qur’a
By:abdalaziz ariff / indiana
Date: Thursday, 4 July 2019, 7:20 pm

Sayings of Prophet Muhammad[AS]: Hadith or Qur’an??

“Hadith is the sayings of Prophet Muhammad(AS), that’s why I can’t deny it!” – That’s the claim made by Hadithers when they are asked about their beliefs on Hadith. In that article, we will try to explore the truth. Image

Hadith: Sayings of Prophet??

Is Hadith the saying of Prophet or not? That question can be answered in the followting brief discussion between Muslim and Hadither:

1st Person=1p

2nd Person=2p

1p:What is Hadith??
2p: Hadith is the Sayings of Prophet.

1p: How do you know that?? and How can you say that??
2p: Bukhari collected Hadiths very critically and he traveled from place-to-place in the search of the truth and he observed and studied the nature of Narrators very critically…

1p:So, how do you know that Bukhari did so and how can you say that none of the narrators deceived the Bukhari???
2p: Bukhari couldn’t be deceived and he couldn’t lie…

1p: How do you know that??
2p: You kaafir….Hadith Refuter…!

“Have you noticed those who were given guidance through the previous scriptures? When they are invited to uphold this Book of God, to judge their disputes and apply it in their lives, a party among them declines and turns away.” Al Qur’an 3:23

It is clear therefore that recorded hadiths of Bukhar, Moslim and etc, are considered qoul(speeches/utterance/sayings) of rasool-e-kareem just on the basis of assumption or Mullah’s theory! We have no evidences to prove that assumption a fact. Because, it is concerned with history and history is made by man and varies from person-to-person, and it contains the bundles of lies. Such as, History tells that Lawrence of Arabia was sent as an architect but what’s the reality?? very few of us knows… No conjecture/assumption is allowed to be followed:

“And you shall not follow blindly any information of which you have no direct knowledge. (Using your faculties of perception and conception) you must verify it for yourself. In the Court of your Lord, you will be held accountable for your hearing, sight, and the faculty of reasoning”Al Qur’an 17:36

Glorious Qur’an: Qoul of Rasool-e-kareem.

Now, we have two hadiths(qouls), known as qouls of Rasool-e-Kareem:
1. Qur’an

“Certainly, this is the Qoul of a noble messenger” Al Qur’an 69:40
” It is a revelation from the Rabb-ul-Alaamen.” Al Qur’an 69:43

God is witness about the authenticity of first one, on being the qoul of rasool e kareem, while the 2nd is considered qoul of rasool e karrem on the basis of assumption or conjecture. So, which one makes sense to be authentic. Of course, the first one, because God is witness about its authenticity and its superiority upon each and every Hadiths beside it:

“God has now revealed the best Hadith…” Al Qur’an 39:23

Even that, God also commands not to believe any hadith beside it:

“These are the verses of God We convey to you with truth. Then, in what HADITH, if not in God and His verses, will they believe?” Al Qur’an 45:6

Qur’an is only the Hadith, which is the source of law for Islam, beside Qur’an, no hadith Prophet is source of law:

“Say, “Shall I seek for Judge and Ruler someone other than God? He is the One Who has revealed this Book, well expounded in detail for you.” Those whom We have given the Book know that this is revealed in truth from your Lord. Be not among those who argue for the sake of argument.” Al Qur’an 6:114

And, no master is allowed to be followed beside that Hadith:

“You shall all follow what has been revealed to you from your Lord and follow no masters other than Him. How seldom do you keep this in mind!” Al Qur’an 7:3

So, how can we believe any other hadith beside Qur’an? why do we need to obey the other qoul best the authentic and best qoul of rasool-e-kareem?? while it is complete(6:114) and fully detailed(6:115). How can you violate the laws of God for your scholar??? like some Christians, who started to obey their scholars….. Qur’an is easy to understand:

“We have made the Qur’an easy to understand. Then, is there any who will learn?” Al Qur’an 54:17

Salamun Aluikum!(6:54)