Our Beacon Forum

Vedic legacies is the Kalash tribe of Chitral, Pak
By:Sirish Dave, Haryana
Date: Thursday, 12 January 2017, 2:47 pm

On Wed, 11 Jan, 2017 at 4:22 pm, shirish dave to ramdas

Unfortunately you have not read Vedas. You even do not know the what is Paniniun and what is Unpaninian. You do not know the astronomical evidences and carbon dating. You do not know the Demise of AIT.
I am not here to reproduce all these here.

I have told you what has been written in Vedas. I can also pin point if you say some thing on misinterpretation of Koran. I have Koran and I have read it. You do not have Vedas, Upnishadas and Puranas.

THE MAIN THING IS PANINI HAS WRITTEN GRAMMER OF SANSKRIT. HE HAPPENED TO BE 800 BCE.

THERE ARE MAINLY THREE TYPES OF SANSKRIT. PANINIAN SANSKRIT, UNPANINIAN SANSKRIT AND VEDIC SANSKRIT. PANINIAN SANSKRIT IS THE LATEST ONE. VEDIC IS THE OLDEST ONE.

I HAVE KORAN WITH HINDI TRANSLATION AND IN ORIGINAL. I HAVE READ IT TWICE. I HAVE ALSO KORAN IN GUJARATI. I HAVE KORAN-SAAR OF VINOBA BHAVE.

I HAVE NOT DEVELOPED ANY HABIT OF MISQUOTING. I TAKE THE MEANING OF MUSLIMS ON KORAN WHAT THEY MEAN. I DO NOT ACCEPT ANY TRANSLATION NON-MUSLIM DID. I DO NOT DO ANY ADVENTURE LIKE YOU. THIS IS MY CULTURE.
--------------------------

Unfortunately you do not know what I know and do not know.
This all knowing attitude is the reason behind cultural degradation of Hindus.

Panini wrote Ashtaddhaya (18 chapters).
He was born in today's Baluchistan.

Indian Hindus even 2 decades ago were prone to believe today's Indian geography existed for Hindus since Vedic era!

Latter they came to know the geographical areas they have been familiar with through Vedas are located within Pakistan.

The only people who carries some sort of vedic legacies is the Kalash tribe of Chitral, Pakistan.

Indian Hindus are grounded on self made falsehoods not on historical reality.

BTW, you might have misread the Qur'an.
If you were an honest reader you had no choice but to leave Hindutva.

Panini set the rules of Sanskrit grammar.
He was not the author of any vedic hymn.
During his days not a single vedic hymn was written.