Okay, thanks for your comments. I don't love Ghamdi; if you search some of my posts you will notice that. That said, I try not my dislike for someone cloud my judgement (and that is what our Book demands). This is an era of Youtube and Facebook. People don't have the time to read lengthy articles and books. Those (including myself) who got offended by Ghamdi's criticism of Parwez are requested to take him on and record a rebuttal. If there is silence, then, (ring !!) the round goes to Ghamdi.