Our Beacon Forum

Are beards obligatory for devout Muslim men?
By:Professor Muhammad Abdel Haleem (N2I)
Date: Sunday, 27 June 2010, 12:39 am

Are beards obligatory for devout Muslim men?

Professor Muhammad Abdel Haleem

Hizbul-Islam militants in Somalia ordered men in Mogadishu this week to grow their beards and trim their moustaches.

"Anyone found violating this law will face the consequences, " a Hizbul-Islam militant said, announcing the edict.

But, is growing a beard obligatory under Islam?

Professor Muhammad Abdel Haleem, of the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London, says it is not.

It is up to the individual whether he lets his facial hair grow or not, Mr Abdel Haleem says, attributing this view to most scholars of Islamic law across a majority of Muslim-dominated countries.

Recommendation

Muslims learn about the Prophet's views on facial hair not from the Koran, but through hadith - or sayings - attributed to Muhammad.

One such hadith, related by Muslim scholar Sahih Bukhari centuries ago, stipulates: "Cut the moustaches short and and leave the beard."

The Prophet Muhammad is believed to have had a beard and those who insist that devout Muslims grow beards argue that they are doing no more than asking the faithful to emulate the Prophet's actions.

Iraqi Shia lawmaker Jamal Al-Deen Many Shia Muslims sport closely cropped beards

The question that arises is one of enforcement.

Mr Abdel Haleem says the body of Islamic law at the core of manuals of Muslim practice puts it as a recommendation - sitting in the middle between an order and absolute free choice.

But, he adds, it is "a recommendation nonetheless" .

The Taliban, who ruled Afghanistan until they were ousted in 2001, and the Islamists of Somalia, are among a small minority in the Muslim world who demand unconditional observance and threaten penalties for non-compliance, says Mr Abdel Haleem.

Every practising Muslim, he argues - adding that he is one of them - should be free to exercise their choice, without fear of retribution.

Imam Abduljalil Sajid, who is based at the Brighton Islamic Mission in the UK, concurs.

"Going without a beard became a sign of modernity" - Abduljalil Sajid Imam

"In my opinion, this is a bit like the issue of women wearing headscarves. It is not one of the compulsory pillars of Islam, like prayer or fasting."

There are, however, schools of Islamic law - Hanafi, Maliki, Hanbali and Shafi - which, among many other things, appear to promote the sporting of prominent beards.

By contrast, followers of Shia Islam generally prefer closely cropped beards, which are mostly "like two, or three days' growth".

Most Islamic scholars or other figures of religious authority, whether Shia or Sunni, sport beards in emulation of the Prophet.

However Egypt, Jordan and Turkey are an exception, says Imam Abduljalil. In these countries you would find some scholars without beards.

"Going without a beard became a sign of modernity," the imam explains. "In the 1960s and 1970s, you saw more Muslims shaving off their beards."

But more "fundamentalist Muslims" he says, continue to follow every letter of the Prophet's teachings today.

The hadith, he says, offers guidelines on "how to trim your beard and keep it looking beautiful."
P Think Green

Red portion of above photos means shaved.

Beards, past and present

The beard, in modern usage, refers to the hair grown on a man's face (chin and cheek); while "mustache" or "moustache" refers to the hair on the upper lip.

The bearded races of mankind have commonly held the beard in high honor. It is the sign of full manhood; the very young male or the eunuch is beardless, and the bearded woman was considered to be witch. Adam, the primal man, and the God and prophets of many faiths have been traditionally pictured with beards, as were kings and nobles and dignitaries.

Beards have assumed all shapes and lengths, some being cultivated to lengths exceeding a man's height while Islamic people still hold the beard in high esteem.

Egyptian-style beard example for high-ranking Egyptians
* The earliest records indicate that the highest ranking Egyptians grew hair on their chins.
* They frizzed, dyed or hennaed (moderate or strong reddish brown to strong brown), and sometimes plaited the beard with interwoven gold thread.
* Later, a metal, false beard or postiche, which was a sign of sovereignty, was worn by queens as well as kings.
* This was held in place by a ribbon tied over the head and attached to a gold chin strap, a fashion existing from about 3000 B.C. To 1580 B.C.
Egyptian postiche or false beard.
An example of a Mesopotamian civilization beard style

The Mesopotamian civilizations (Chaldean, Babylonian, Assyrian, Median, Aramean, and ancient Persian) devoted great care to oiling and dressing their beards, using tongs or curling irons to create elaborate ringlets and frizzles, in a tiered effect
Mesopotamian beard style.
* Assyrians resorted to a black dye for eyebrows, hair, and beard; while the Persians used henna which produced an orange-red color, a style that existed from 1900 B.C.
* Gold dust, gold thread, and scented yellow starch were sometimes used in the hair and the beard for festive occasions.
* In ancient India and Turkey, the beard was allowed to grow long, a symbol of dignity and of wisdom.
* To cut the beard was infamy among the Turks; slaves were shaved as a mark of servility.
Jewish patriarchal beard style

Patriarchs of the tribes of Israel grew beards embellished by a hanging earlock (peyot); the peyot is still worn by some very pious orthodox Jews.
Jewish patriarch beard.
The Greeks and one of their beard styles

Beards predominated among the Greeks until 323 B.C., at which time Alexanter the Great ordered his soldiers to be clean shaven, fearing that their beards would serve as handles for their enemies to grab and to hold the Greek soldier as he was killed.

Grecian beards were frequently curled with tongs to create hanging curls.
Greek style beard.

The Etruscans of northern Italy (about 1000 B.C.) favored the Asian fashion of the long beard, which was eventually handed on to the Romans.
One of the Roman styles of beards

The Romans apparently thought the Greek style of curled beard was too effeminate, and preferred a trim, well-groomed shape.
The Roman beard, more masculine.
* The use of the razor was encouraged in Rome by Lucius Tarquinius Priscus (616-578 B.C.), in an effort towards hygienic reform.
* Shaving did not come into general use until about 454 B.C., when a group of Greek Sicilin barbers went to the mainland from Sicily.
* Barber shops were situated on the main streets, but were patronized only by those who could not afford to have slaves.
* The Greeks and Romans of the ancient days mostly shaved, and the term barbarous (beard-wearing) was applied for a long period to people who were considered out of the realm of polite society.
* Scipio Africanus, according to Pliny, was the first Roman to shave daily.
* Philosophers continued to keep their beards.
A Byzantine beard style

The Byzantine civilizaton favored beards and mustaches, and the hair moderately short, a combination of oriental and Roman origin, which later influenced medieval and Renaissance Europe.

From the 7th to 16th centuries, the beards of Byzantium were curled, split on the center of the chin, square cut or pointed and some were extremely long.
Byzantine, Saracenic or Moorish beard style.

By the end of the 12th century, the Greek, Roman, and oriental influences disappeared, and the cities of Florence and Venice began to set the mode for the courts of Europe.
European transitions
* Until the advent of Christianity in the 7th century, all Anglo-Saxons wore beards; members of the clergy were then compelled by law to shave.
* English princes wore mustaches until William I by law (1066-87) compelled them to cut them off in accordance with the Norman fashion.
* The Crusades were perhaps accountable for the return of beards, and for more than four centuries great diversity was allowed: beards, mustaches, and shaven faces all coexisted.
* The Renaissance fashion in Europe included both clean-shaven faces and beards varying in shape and length.
* Many men starched their beards in the 1560s.

In England, Henry VIII (1509-47) brought the beard back into favor in 1535, after which beards of all shapes and lengths were worn.
Henry VIII brought the beard back into fashion.
The Vandyke style became popular for many men

The Flemish painter, Sir Anthony Vandyke (1599-1641) painted so many aristocrats with a pointed type of beard that it became known as the Vandyke beard. They were dressed with pomade or wax, applied with a tiny brush and comb.
Vandyke style was popular late 1500s and early 1600s.

Other gadgets were used to keep the mustache and beard in shape while sleeping.

There were many other beard styles over the centuries a few of which are shown here
French and Dutch

In 1637, Louis XIII triumphed over the Spanish influence when he amused himself by shaving his courtiers, leaving only a tiny lip beard "a la royale" or "la mouche", a custom adopted by the French and Dutch cavaliers.

Napoleonic

The "imperial", a pointed tuft of whiskers on the chin, was named in honor of Napolean III, in the 19th century.

Vandyke style was popular late 1500s and early 1600s.

In the 19th century, long side whiskers merging into a mustache became known as the "Franz Josef" in honor of the emperor of Austria.

Mutton chops beards were popular in the Victorian period.

During the Victorian period, from about 1840 to 1870, London set the fashion for the world. Side whiskers developed a longer, more luxuriant growth and were sometimes referred to as "mutton chops" or "Piccadily weepers".