There was no need for Tarek Fatah to go into history in this much detail.
It should be easy for anyone and everyone to understand that if the exalted Prophet Muhammad violated a single commandment of the Qur'an, all his noble companions would have left him alone in one single day.
See what the Qur'an has to say about the marriageable age.
THE MARRIAGEABLE AGE
The beginning of the physiological cycles in a girl and nocturnal emissions in a boy are commonly believed to be their age of marriage. To the unfortunate Mullah, everything revolves around sex. A Hadith of Bukhari atrociously tells us that a girl can have Nikah (the marital contract) at 6 and the marriage can be consummated at age 9 since the exalted Prophet did that with Hazrat Ayesha! Is there any wonder that the West call him a child-molester? Why don't then the Sunnah-peddlers "marry off" their daughters at 6 and 9? Many countries set an arbitrary 16 years for the girl and 18 years for the boy.
The Divine Wisdom enshrined in the Qur’an makes things so sensible. It sets up three rational criteria:
1 - Sufficient maturity to grant consent.
2 - Ability to sign a legal contract.
3 - Competence to take care of one's own finances.
FINANCES+CONSENT+CONTRACT: 4:6 Train and educate the orphans well and test them. When they reach the age of marriage and attain sound judgment, release their property to them. The marriageable age shall mean attainment of physical and mental maturity when one can express free consent and legally make a solemn contract (4:21). ----.
CONSENT: 4:19 O You who have chosen to be graced with belief! It is not lawful for you to force women into marrying or holding on to them in marriage against their will. ---.
SOLEMN CONTRACT: 4:21 And how could you take the marital gift back from her after you have lived intimately with each other and after she has taken from you a very Solemn Pledge of the marital contract?
How can a child give free consent, sign a solemn contract and manage financial matters?
Wafa Sultan is reported to have been born in a Christian family and fakes herself as a convert from Islam. Can she refute our line of argument?