I felt when Dr Shabbir saab said that he found the reasoning in Dr Qamars' work questionable, and I have not been shown any logical explanation for why fatsing is not part of the overall package that Saum seems to be, then I wanted to show how easy it is to distort the Quran by taking clear verses and making them allegorical. Some members missed the meaning of why I wrote this, I was not advocating eating pork!
I respect everyones views but I found both works by Dr Qamar and Mr Sherazi a little too far beyond what all other great scholars of the past and present have shown saum to be. Sir Syed was said not to fast but what did he say in his explanation of the Quran?
I am still open to change if further evidence is provided.