The books and articles I have read so far did not show any malice towards Islam or Muslims. However, as Sister UmeAimon pointed out, there are some inconstancies and lack of coherence at some places. I have noted them and brought some to the attention of Dr. Qamar. However, I am extremely PATIENT. I can wait until Dr. Qamar visits his daughter in USA. Then, we will be able to discuss and clear up everything. If we are truly TRUTH seekers, nobody can fool us. Whether Dr. Qamar is a sincere reformer or an imposter or a gangster the truth will come out sooner or later. Please be patient.
Let me point out here that it is extremely hard to reform even a single person. Here we are trying to reform the whole Ummah. This task needs highest level of PATIENCE and PERSEVERANCE.
Please remember that as Muslims we are not supposed to indulge in slandering, backbiting, or bad mouthing. Please study and follow the Code of Conduct prescribed in the Quran. Then, you will learn how to protect yourselves from these malicious bugs that can destroy your character.