Brother Habib’s objections on “Haqiqat-e-Soam” are not new. Another brother A. S. Ansari raised similar objections on the book. Brother Dr. Qamar Zaman had no problem shooting down all objections thrown at the book. Please be patient. Once the English translation of the book is complete all brothers/sisters, who do not know Urdu, will be able to read it. In the meantime I will try to translate some excerpts from Dr. Qamar’s reply to A. S. Ansari and post them on the Forum. Then, you will be the judge. Please try to be fair and honest in your judgment.