Dear Syed Habib,
To be perfectly honest with you I simply cannot read Urdu so Dr Zaman's book had absolutely nothing to do with my conclusions. I was just elated to find out that he had written on this topic and came to the same conclusions as myself and I am eager to read and/or hear his thoughts expressed in English Language.
I came to my conclusions through MY OWN research, studying, reflecting, questioning and pondering on the Quran and this process for me began during last year's annual ritual fasting. I enjoy reading authors such as Dr. Uncle Shabbir and others like him to help me fill in the holes of my own independent research and study but I do not base my conclusions entirely on books written by authority figures. You must do what Allah has COMMANDED of us all and study The Quran and draw your own conclusions based on your own research and reflection. To read books written by "man" and base your decisions and conclusions solely on that is not the way to go about it.