SALAM TO ALL,
I am agree with brother Zubair , I have my own opinion about Dr Qamar Zaman book in which he wrote that the sick and the traveler are not phisical related to fast . As my understanding is, That when a person is sick, He or she is kind of depress so from a depress person you can not axpect patience during ramadan and the same is with the traveler that is why God let excemption for them for a while when they are in that situation. But for the rest of us yes it will be a good training for us because we are human beings and pron to mistakes the training will keep us grounded and well on the right behaviour if we are willing to do . Brother Zubair wrote that doctors graduate from theirs training, yes but they are learning certian things to get a degree their real learning starts when they start their practice, if they stop that practice what will happen for supose after ten years they offcourse still will be doctors but out of touch with new things.So practice is essentional to keep things up to date, but what we are doing just eating, sleeping,and complaining all the time because of Ramadan. It is now a traning of cooking.What good are we doing?